Author Archives: Scalper1
ETF Update: John Hancock, Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan And More Launched Funds This Week
Welcome back to the SA ETF Update. My goal is to keep Seeking Alpha readers up to date on the ETF universe and to gain some visibility, both for the ETF community, and for me as its editor (so users know who to approach with issues, article ideas, to become a contributor, etc.) Every weekend, or every other weekend (depending on the reader response and submission volumes), we will highlight fund launches and closures for the week, as well as any news items that could impact ETF investors. Last week we saw the first Goldman Sachs (NYSE: GS ) ETF enter the arena, the ActiveBeta U.S. Large Cap Equity ETF (NYSEARCA: GSLC ). While there was a followup launch from GS this week, John Hancock made the biggest splash with its first 6 ETF offerings. The newcomer has a strong history in mutual funds and I am excited to see how these new ETFs perform in the coming months. Fund launches for the week of September 28, 2015 Another Goldman ETF opens for business (9/29): One week after the launch of GSLC, Goldman Sachs rolls out one for emerging markets , the Goldman Sachs ActiveBeta Emerging Markets ETF (NYSEARCA: GEM ). John Hancock adds 6 new funds (9/29): As stated by Andrew G. Arnott, president and CEO of John Hancock Investments, “it was important to us to develop an ETF product that seeks to address investor needs for performance potential, backed by an investment approach rooted in decades of academic research.” They are the John Hancock Multifactor Mid Cap ETF (NYSEARCA: JHMM ), the John Hancock Multifactor Large Cap ETF (NYSEARCA: JHML ), the John Hancock Multifactor Technology ETF (NYSEARCA: JHMT ), the John Hancock Multifactor Healthcare ETF (NYSEARCA: JHMH ) and John Hancock Multifactor Financials ETF (NYSEARCA: JHMF ). John Hancock doesn’t seem to have pages for the 6 funds yet, but the SEC filing linked above should be a good starting point for interested investors. JPMorgan (NYSE: JPM ) launches a new U.S. Equity ETF (9/30): The JPMorgan Diversified Return U.S. Equity ETF (NYSEARCA: JPUS ) tracks the Russell 1000 Diversified Factor Index , which “seeks to provide U.S. exposure with the potential for better risk-adjusted returns.” Credit Suisse rolls out an income ETF (9/30): The Credit Suisse X-Links Multi-Asset High Income ETN (NYSEARCA: MLTI ) tracks an index “comprised of a broad, diversified basket of up to 120 publicly-traded securities that historically have paid high dividends or distributions.” IndexIQ launches a new fund-of-funds ETF (9/30): The IQ Leaders GTAA Tracker ETF (NYSEARCA: QGTA ) follows the IQ Leaders GTAA Index, which “seeks to track the performance and risk characteristics of the 10 leading global allocation mutual funds. Identifying 10 leading mutual funds is based on fund performance and asset size and is reconstituted annually.” iShares launches a hedged alternative to Japanese equities (10/1): The iShares Currency Hedged JPX-Nikkei 400 ETF (NYSEMKT: HJPX ) “seeks to track the investment results of a broad-based benchmark composed of Japanese equities.” It is a hedged alternative for the iShares JPX-Nikkei 400 ETF (JPXN). There were no fund closures for the week of September 28, 2015 One of the first comments on my article last week raised an important question : The ETF world is ever changing. Smart beta was a new thing recently. Similarly I saw few articles that talked about ETMF (Exchange Traded Mutual Funds) being the next big thing. Would love to see some research on it.. Our own Jonathon Liss came up with an answer that I feel many readers will find incredibly helpful as ETMFs start to gain traction in the market: ETMFs are not really ETFs. In fact, I think the term is intentionally confusing in an attempt to ride the popularity of ETFs. In most key ways, these products are no different than mutual funds. The fact they are ‘exchange-listed’ is meaningless for all intents and purposes. They only price once a day and are non-transparent meaning they only have to list their holdings once per quarter akin to MFs – and on a 1-2 month delay at that as is standard with 13F filings. Additionally, they have a strange auction bidding system required to buy them. They do likely share some of the theoretical tax advantages of ETFs but that’s about it. Thus, I think they should essentially be lumped with mutual funds and not ETFs. If I’m missing key details I’d be happy for others to fill me in but this is what I’ve been able to gather from the literature I’ve seen. Have any other questions on ETFs or ETNs? Please comment below and I will try to clear things up. As an author and editor I have found that constructive feedback is the best way to grow. What you would like to see discussed in the future? How can I improve this series to meet reader needs? Please share your thoughts on this first edition of the ETF Update series in the comments section below. Have a view on something that’s coming up or a new fund? Submit an article. Share this article with a colleague
Simple Pair – Switching Bond Strategy Using Mutual Funds
Summary This strategy switches between a high yield corporate bond fund and a high yield municipal bond fund based on 3-month returns. A 3-month simple moving average filter is also used. The strategy is very low risk (i.e. low standard deviation and low maximum drawdown) while maintaining reasonable growth (~10% CAGR). Backtesting from 1986 using FAGIX and MMHYX produces CAGR = 11.3%, standard deviation = 5.5%, and maximum drawdown (based on monthly returns) = -5.5%. There are essentially no losing years. No load/no fee mutual funds must be selected for practical application. They are platform-dependent; for Schwab, I selected JAHYX and NHMAX as the best available no load/no fee mutual funds. Using JAHYX and NMHAX and backtesting to 2000, the strategy produces CAGR = 9.7%, standard deviation = 4.8%, and maximum drawdown = -3.5%. There are no losing years. This article explains a rather simple strategy that tactically switches between a high-yield corporate bond mutual fund and a high-yield municipal bond mutual fund, with money market being a safety net. The goal was to develop a low risk, capital-preservation strategy with reasonable growth (CAGR ~ 10%). I also desired to use mutual funds rather than ETFs to reduce volatility. This necessitated that the strategy be updated on a quarterly basis rather than a monthly basis (my usual preference). The reason these two bond asset classes were chosen was because they are not well-correlated; typically, their correlation is about 0.15. To show the feasibility of the strategy, I used two representative mutual funds that could be backtested to 1986 in Portfolio Visualizer (PV): Fidelity Capital and Income Fund (MUTF: FAGIX ) and MFS Municipal High Yield Bond Fund (MUTF: MMHYX ). Some might object to the usage of FAGIX as the high-yield corporate bond mutual fund because a small percentage of the fund is invested in equities rather than bonds. Fidelity Advisor High Income Advantage Class A (MUTF: FAHDX ) is actually a better representative of this class, but its history starts in 1987 in PV. I wanted to include 1987 in the analysis, so I used FAGIX instead of FAHDX. But I will show results using both FAGIX and FAHDX later in this article. The strategy uses 3-month relative strength momentum ranking to determine which asset to pick each quarter. In addition, the top-ranked asset must pass a 3-month simple moving average, MA, filter in order to be selected. If the asset does not pass this filter, then the money goes to the money market. This is a pretty simple set of parameters, and others have shown that a 3-month lookback period for bonds is most satisfactory. The backtesting was performed using the free Portfolio Visualizer (PV) software. Any investor can run these calculations and trade this strategy. The backtest results are shown below for FAGIX and MMHYX. CASHX (PV’s ticker for money market) is the cash filter asset. The timeframe is 1986 – present. It can be seen that the CAGR = 11.3%, the standard deviation, SD = 5.5%, the maximum drawdown based on monthly returns (MaxDD) = -5.5%, and the worst year = -0.3%. Risk adjustment return-on-investment can be seen using CAGR/SD and/or CAGR/MaxDD. In this strategy, CAGR/SD = 2.04, and CAGR/MaxDD = 2.02. Summary Table for FAGIX – MMHYX: 1986 – present (click to enlarge) Total Return for FAGIX – MMHYX: 1986 – present (click to enlarge) Annual Returns for FAGIX – MMHYX: 1986 – present (click to enlarge) It should be noted that results are also shown for an equal-weight portfolio, i.e. both assets are held continually and rebalanced annually. This is commonly referred to as a buy & hold strategy. The equal-weight strategy has a CAGR of 7.7%, but it has a MaxDD of -27.6% and a worst year return of -25.9%. The benefit of the tactical strategy I am proposing can readily be seen: almost 50% higher growth compared to the passive buy & hold strategy (CAGR of 11.3% versus 7.7%) and much less drawdown (-5.5% versus -27.6%). If FAHDX is substituted for FAGIX, the backtest timeframe becomes 1988 – present. The results are shown below. It can be seen that CAGR = 10.5%, SD = 5.6%, MaxDD = 6.5%, and worst year = +0.2%. The CAGR/SD = 1.89, and CAGR/MaxDD = 1.62. Summary Table for FAHDX – MMHYX: 1988 – present (click to enlarge) Total Return for FAHDX – MMHYX: 1988 – present (click to enlarge) Now comes the difficult task of picking mutual funds for a real application of the strategy. I needed to find mutual funds with no loads and no redemption fees, and operating expenses (including 12b-1 fees) that are kept to a minimum. Of course, every platform has different funds that meet these requirements. I use the Schwab platform, and they provide a lot of no load/no fee options. After extensive searching, I selected Janus High-Yield T Shs Fund (MUTF: JAHYX ) as the best high yield corporate bond mutual fund, and Nuveen High Yield Municipal Bond Fund Class A (MUTF: NHMAX ) as the best high yield municipal bond mutual fund. These funds only permit backtesting to 2000. So the results shown below have a timeframe from 2000 – present. It can be seen that CAGR = 9.7%, SD = 4.8%, MaxDD = -3.4%, and the worst year = +1.6%. The CAGR/SD = 2.03, and the CAGR/MaxDD = 2.66 (a very good number). Summary Table for JAHYX – NHMAX: 2000 – Present (click to enlarge) Total Return for JAHYX – NHMAX: 2000 – Present (click to enlarge) Annual Returns for JAHYX – NHMAX: 2000 – Present (click to enlarge) The robustness of the strategy is seen in the table below. The MA has been varied between 2 months and 4 months, and the lookback timing period (TP) was changed between 3 months and 4 months. The overall results do not change appreciably. Robustness of Strategy (click to enlarge) In summary, this article presents a very conservative tactical strategy that produces reasonable growth with very low risk. It is a quarterly updating strategy that uses less volatile mutual funds rather than ETFs. The basic strategy can be implemented on any platform, but care must be exercised in finding the best no load/no fee mutual funds for any given platform. For the Schwab platform, I believe the best mutual funds for this strategy are JAHYX and NHMAX. The pick for last quarter (July – September, 2015) was CASHX. The selection for this quarter (October – December, 2015) is NHMAX.