Author Archives: Scalper1

What Deleveraging May Mean For Netflix And Many Of Your Favorite Stocks

One way or another, debt extremes eventually give way to deleveraging. The exact forces that push a high-flyer to incredible heights can send it plummeting 20,000 leagues beneath sea level. And while it is certainly possible that the Fed can deftly maneuver in the near-term, longer-term investors need to be more vigilant. You know those annoying notifications that chime on your cell phone in the middle of the work day? The ones that sound off to let you know when Kim Kardashian’s daughter sits on a commode? Or when Donald Trump insults a member of the media? I get far too many of those. I’ve tried playing with the notification settings on the apps on my iPhone, but somehow, I still get a ton of unwanted messages. Last week, I received a Yahoo Finance notification shortly after the stock market closed shop. The one-liner? “Stocks soar on judgment that Fed will delay rate hike.” Let that sink in for a moment. Stocks are not rocketing because investors are confident about corporate profitability or sales. They’re not climbing due to jobs optimism or economic acceleration. The Dow moved higher for seven consecutive trading sessions (through Monday 10/12) because – in spite of seven years of 0% overnight lending rates – the U.S. economy is still too weak for a token tightening gesture. No doubt about it. This is not the 80s or the 90s anymore. Years ago, money managers, institutional traders and the overall investment community owned stock assets because public corporations were likely to grow their businesses in a strong U.S. expansion. Now? Investors own equities because the “no-go” economy still requires unimaginably cheap credit. So what’s the big deal about leaving interest rates so low for so long? One reason is excess speculation. For example, plenty of folks own Netflix (NASDAQ: NFLX ) and they have enjoyed a number of years of extraordinary price gains. More recently, however, folks have leveraged account values in order to own even more shares of NFLX. Just as homeowners in 2005 used cash-out refinancing to acquire additional properties with negligible down payments, NFLX shareholders have used rising account values in margin accounts to buy more NFLX stock. As shares of the media giant rise – as NFLX begins looking like a no-lose proposition – speculators employ more leverage to acquire even more shares of NFLX. And why the heck wouldn’t you borrow to buy more? The Fed’s going to make sure that stocks won’t fall, right? Borrowing money for the purpose of leveraging a stock position is known as margin debt . It has been a profitable venture for anyone who arrived early at the reflated asset price party. Of course, parties eventually end. Those who overstay their welcome or who arrive late will will find themselves nursing monstrous losses. Consider the fact that NYSE margin debt cracked at an all-time high near the $500 billion mark in April. By September, margin debt sank 6.7%, down to $473 billion. Why might this matter? There have only been four times since the turn of the century when margin debt pulled back by 6.7% or more – April 2000, August 2007, May 2010 and August 2011. Those are some relatively inauspicious dates. Granted, 2010 turned out to be a short-lived correction in the early stages of the current bull market. The other three occasions – the dot-come tech wreck, the worldwide financial collapse and the euro-zone crisis – resulted in massive drawdowns for world stock benchmarks. Margin debt deterioration is, of course, deleveraging within the stock market. Not only does it signal a lack of confidence that the borrowing-to-buy game can continue indefinitely, but significant declines in markets themselves trigger margin calls that, ultimately, force the sale of the underlying assets. Now let’s revisit shares of Netflix. Margin debt is a function of the underlying “collateral.” Forced liquidation subsequently reduces the value of the collateral (NFLX) which triggers still more margin calls and additional liquidation. The exact forces that push a high-flyer to incredible heights can send it plummeting 20,000 leagues beneath sea level. (Note: My intent is not to pick on Netflix; rather, I am highlighting how leverage often destroys the best laid plans.) How enthusiastic have speculators been relative to actual economic activity here in the fall of 2015? Margin debt as a percentage of GDP is close to 3%; in the fall of 2000 and in the fall of 2007, margin debt-to-GDP hit 2.4% and 2.3% respectively. And it’s not just margin debt that suggests leverage is hitting obscene levels. According to recent research conducted by McKinsey, total debt (consumer, business, government, financial) as a percentage of GDP has surpassed the extremes of 2007: 286% versus 269%. $57 trillion of fresh debt across 7 years at a rate of 5.3%, far outpacing the 2.2% growth in GDP. As my daughter might inquire, “Who’s gonna pay for that?” Optimists say that when consumers use their credit cards at H&M, when drivers take out auto loans for Audis, when students acquire loans for their $40,000-per-year education, the activity shows confidence in the future. And after all, they tell us, the ability to service the debt is all that matters. On the other hand, if debt is expanding at a faster rate than economic activity, will the day not come when the expansion of that debt surpasses the ability to service it? If consumer credit as a percentage of GDP was insanely high at 17.5% leading into the financial meltdown circa 2007, how are people better off when it is at 19.5%? Or should we simply assume the Federal Reserve will be able to keep borrowing costs near historic lows forever? Debt cannot increase indefinitely. Like an economy itself, expansion gives way to contraction. There are credit cycles just as sure as their are business cycles. We should not be surprised, then, that the Bank of International Settlements (BIS), the International Monetary Fund (NYSE: IMF ) and the German finance minister have all warned about extremely high debt ratios the world over. Each have used terms like “dangerous over-leveraging” and “credit panic,” while simultaneously fretting a global financial system that would be vulnerable to any amount of monetary tightening by the U.S. Federal Reserve. Can you say, “Catch 22?” One way or another, debt extremes eventually give way to deleveraging. And while it is certainly possible that the Fed can deftly maneuver in the near-term – prompting the federal government as well as American businesses, consumers and market speculators to keep borrowing freely – longer-term investors need to be more vigilant. In essence, one’s equity component should focus on low volatility and quality at this juncture. Consider the iShares MSCI USA Quality Factor ETF (NYSEARCA: QUAL ) and/or the iShares USA Minimum Volatility ETF (NYSEARCA: USMV ). If you’re going to own individual securities, even in a downturn, you will want to think in terms of low leverage companies like Costco (NASDAQ: COST ) and low volatile corporations like PepsiCo (NYSE: PEP ). What’s more, you may want to resist the temptation in thinking that the worst is over for previous momentum standouts like the SPDR Biotech ETF (NYSEARCA: XBI ). Disclosure: Gary Gordon, MS, CFP is the president of Pacific Park Financial, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser with the SEC. Gary Gordon, Pacific Park Financial, Inc, and/or its clients may hold positions in the ETFs, mutual funds, and/or any investment asset mentioned above. The commentary does not constitute individualized investment advice. The opinions offered herein are not personalized recommendations to buy, sell or hold securities. At times, issuers of exchange-traded products compensate Pacific Park Financial, Inc. or its subsidiaries for advertising at the ETF Expert web site. ETF Expert content is created independently of any advertising relationships.

GoPro estimates slashed on slowdown in camera demand

With negative sentiment weighing on GoPro (GPRO) stock, Dougherty & Company analyst Charles Anderson on Tuesday slashed his price target to 32 from 70. Anderson, though, also reiterated his buy rating on GoPro stock due to its current valuation. GoPro went public in June 2014 at 24 and ended its first day of trading at 31.34. It climbed to as high as 98.47 in October 2014 — and hit its all-time low of 27.07 on Thursday. In afternoon trading

Do Price Targets Matter In Volatile Markets? (And, Why Alpha Theory Should Be A Starting Point Even In Turbulent Times)

This blog was co-authored with Alpha Theory’s Customer Relations Manager, Dana Lambert. “Stock prices will continue to fluctuate – sometimes sharply – and the economy will have its ups and downs. Over time, however, we believe it is highly probable that the sort of businesses we own will continue to increase in value at a satisfactory rate.” – Warren Buffett, famed investor “While many have portrayed the current environment as a highly risky time to invest, these individuals are likely confusing risk with volatility. We believe risk should be determined based on the probability that an investor will incur a permanent loss of capital. As market values have declined substantially, this risk has actually diminished rather than increased. “- Bill Ackman, Pershing Square 3Q08 Investor Letter The recent market environment has proven challenging for many funds, including Alpha Theory clients. The market has been volatile, but the real challenge is directionality. As of September 28, the S&P was down 11% over the prior 49 trading days, with 30 of the 49 days being down. Alpha Theory clients generally benefit from pure volatility (large ups and downs without a direction) because they are buying on dips and selling on rises (mean-reversion). The problem with a uniformly down directional market is that clients are continually getting indications to add to their longs and trim their shorts – the proverbial “catching the falling knife”. Although Alpha Theory cannot overcome persistent negative correlation between scenario estimates and outcomes – in other words inaccurate research – it does offer three options to help clients deal with these circumstances. OPTION #1 – RAISE PREFERRED RETURN. When the price of an asset falls, its probability-weighted return (PWR) rises. When the PWR rises, the normal action is to increase your position size. But when all asset prices fall, all PWRs rise and thus the longs become more attractive and the shorts less so. This suggested increase in long exposure may not be tenable and there may be a general skepticism regarding the price targets. In this situation, a manager can raise the preferred return for longs and thus raise the ‘hurdle rate’ required to be a full position in his or her fund (i.e., before you required only a 40% PWR to be a full position, but in this market environment you require 60%). This will immediately lower long exposure and only suggest adding to the best ideas. In the extreme example of February 2009, clients raised their hurdle rates to 70% or 80% and were able to see quickly numerous compelling ideas and how to shift capital appropriately. OPTION #2 – RELATIVE INDEX ADJUSTMENT. As the market falls, the “market multiple” decreases – which has ripple effects through the price targets in Alpha Theory. For those who cannot re-underwrite all of their targets for the new market paradigm, the application offers an easy-to-use feature called ‘Relative Index Adjustment’. This basically adds back the move of the market to an asset’s expected return, and the following would be an illustrative example. If the market is down 11%, then most assets’ prices will also be down and their suggested position sizes will increase. Now let’s turn on the Relative Index Adjustment. If every asset is down 11%, commensurate with the market move, then Alpha Theory will adjust the prices so that there is no change (-11% Stock Move minus -11% Market Move = 0% change) and thus no suggested change in position size. The beauty of this system is that you can turn it on and off and the Market Move is calculated since the last price target update. So if an analyst updates a price target, the Market Move gets set back to zero because the analyst would take into account the new “market multiple.” OPTION #3 – RE-UNDERWRITE CONSERVATIVE PRICE TARGETS. Fundamental investors recognize that there is no absolute intrinsic value for each asset because their assumptions are subjective. There is, however, a range of assumptions that span from aggressive to conservative. Down markets imply that pushing your assumptions to the conservative end of the spectrum may be appropriate. After doing this, you can see which assets are still suggested buys and which are not. The confidence imbued by using the most conservative assumptions allows you to be aggressive with add and trim decisions. A few views to help isolate where to start the re-underwriting process are: Performance view : shows those assets that have suffered the most on an absolute and relative basis Group by Risk/Reward within 10% : groups the assets that are within 10% of Reward and 10% of Risk targets (click to enlarge) While consideration of the aforementioned steps certainly is appropriate, as you develop conviction about downward directionality for the market, it is also worth noting that volatile markets can often be followed by periods of relative calm and distinct upwardly-biased directionality – and of course this has been the pattern for the past several years now. So where in one week an analyst or PM sees a 1-year target as likely to be unachievable, the next week suddenly the expected return gap narrows considerably. In short, just when you may be losing faith in your targets, they can quickly fall back into an attainable range. Directional markets that move quickly are challenging for many reasons. It is easy to throw up your hands and rationalize that “price targets don’t matter” or “our research is wrong”. It is hard to restrain those emotions and redouble your efforts to find the value that has been exposed in the quick, volatile relocation of asset prices. To do so requires a rigorous, disciplined process that begins with retesting assumptions (i.e., raising return hurdles, adjusting for the market move, and setting more conservative targets). If, after re-underwriting price targets and portfolio inputs, Alpha Theory is still recommending upsizings, then you can feel confident in your actions … even in a volatile, directional market.