Author Archives: Scalper1

Portfolio Allocations: Bet Sizing

The math that dictates optimal portfolio allocations is complicated and an overly simplistic approach introduces a lot of unnecessary risk. The math of “gambling” and the math of investing share a lot of similarities. I believe the math presented below is equally applicable to both worlds. While EV (Expected Value) is a critical concept, it is meaningless without the concept of EG (Expected Growth). Chip Kelly is not the guy the “Kelly Criterion” is named after, but his presence creates interesting football betting opportunities. As a guy who many would consider to be a “professional gambler,” the concept of bet sizing has been something that I have spent a lot of time thinking about. I firmly believe trading stocks and derivatives for great portfolio managers is not all that different from playing poker for elite poker players. Individual investments for a portfolio manager and individual bets of a poker player (or elite sports handicapper) may be extremely risky, but the entire set of investments that make up a portfolio or long series of bets over time by a “professional gambler” are likely to yield a high return with a relatively low risk over the long run. This article is in response to an Instablog written by one of the most interesting contributors on this site, Chris DeMuth . He gives a relatively simple methodology of how to allocate capital. He presents the basic premise that he will invest around 1.25% of his portfolio in an investment he likes and will increase his position in the stock if he continues to love it as the price declines. He will continue to add to this position until a maximum of 10% of his portfolio is allocated to the individual investment. Adding to an investment that is becoming more undervalued relative to its fair market value makes a lot of sense. However, the exact portfolio allocations he suggests seem to be quite arbitrarily chosen instead of meticulously calculated. Based on my user name, it is probably clear that I have spent a lot of time in my life thinking about the fancy math of endeavors most would consider to be reckless gambling. I would like to introduce the idea of the Kelly Criterion, the most fundamental formula for elite sports gamblers. You can read about it here . What this magic formula does is tell you how much of your portfolio (bankroll) you should invest (bet) on a particular investment in order to maximize the growth of your portfolio given your estimate of the probability of winning and the odds received on the wager. The formula is written below: Every investor (bettor) is familiar with the concept of EV (Expected Value). Everyone knows that positive EV bets are wonderful. However, there is a corresponding concept that is much less well understood. It is the idea of Expected Growth, and frankly, it is equally important to understand as Expected Value when thinking about portfolio allocations. Let’s consider an investment where you are allowed to bet on a game of flipping quarters. The odds of picking a winning bet are 50% when flipping a quarter one time. Let’s also assume that in this generous game that for each flip of the quarter, you are getting a +200 payout. For those of you not familiar with common sports gambling notation, this means that you are given 2-1 on your wager. If you wager $1 on this bet and lose, you will lose $1. However, if you win, you will receive back $3 ($1 for your initial investment and a $2 profit). Better yet, let us assume that there are no caps on how much we are allowed to bet. This is a wonderful game that I would love to play forever everyday if it were readily available. Let’s now further assume you have a bankroll of $1,000,000. You are allowed to play this game only two times. In this game, there are four distinct possible outcomes (the sample space) that each have the same probability of occurring. The 4 possible outcomes are as follows: Win both the first and second bets. Win the first bet, lose the second bet. Lose the first bet, win the second bet. Lose both the first and second bets. Let’s assume that you are conservative and wager 1% of your bankroll on each coin flip. These are the possible outcomes of the size of your bankroll after playing the game of 2 quarter flips. Bankroll = $1,000,000 x (1 + (2 * 0.01)) x (1 + (2 * 0.01)) = $1,040,400 Bankroll = $1,000,000 x (1 + (2 * 0.01)) x (1 – (1 * 0.01)) = $1,009,800 Bankroll = $1,000,000 x (1 – (1 * 0.01)) x (1 + (2 * 0.01)) = $1,009,800 Bankroll = $1,000,000 x (1 – (1 * 0.01)) x (1 – (1 * 0.01)) = $980,100 Since each of these results is equally likely, the Expected Value of the outcome of these sequential bets is a profit of $10,025 (or 1.0025%). Expected Growth (EG) is a little bit more tricky. In order to figure it out (without having the formula in front of you), you must see what the expected outcome is. Since the odds of the game are always 50/50 for each coin flip, the expected outcome is simply winning once for each time you lose. Since we are flipping the coin twice, the expected outcome is to win once and lose once. The order that you win or lose doesn’t matter as the bankroll ends up at the same number either way in this game. The bankroll, based on the calculations above, in the expected outcome is $1,009,800, which is a profit of $9,800 (or 0.98%). This 0.98% is the EG. For those that are interested in generalized equations, here they are: Bankroll after Expected Outcome = (Initial Bankroll) * (1 + (Decimal Odds – 1) * (Bet Size / Initial Bankroll))p * (1 – (Bet Size / Initial Bankroll))(1 – p) EG = (1 + (Decimal odds – 1) * (Bet Size / Initial Bankroll))p * (1 – (Bet Size / Initial Bankroll))(1-p) – 1 EV = ((p * Decimal Odds) – 1) * (Bet Size / Initial Bankroll) where p is the probability of winning Let’s look at a fun example of playing that original game but instead of betting 1% of your bankroll on each coin flip, you want to make a bet with a higher EV and bet 90% of your bankroll. (For those of you still reading at this point, that is far greater than what the Kelly criterion says you should bet.) The 4 possible outcomes are as follows again: Win both the first and second bets. Win the first bet, lose the second bet. Lose the first bet, win the second bet. Lose both the first and second bets. Bankroll = $1,000,000 x (1 + (2 * 0.90)) x (1 + (2 * 0.90)) = $7,840,000 Bankroll = $1,000,000 x (1 + (2 * 0.90)) x (1 – (1 * 0.90)) = $280,000 Bankroll = $1,000,000 x (1 – (1 * 0.90)) x (1 + (2 * 0.90)) = $280,000 Bankroll = $1,000,000 x (1 – (1 * 0.90)) x (1 – (1 * 0.90)) = $10,000 Since each of the 4 outcomes is equally likely, that yields an EV of $2,102,500 or a profit of $1,102,500 (or 110.25%). However, the EG here is a loss of 74%! That means that although you would be making bets with higher expected value, you would end up with (significantly) worse expected growth. In fact, you now expect a significant shrink in the size of your portfolio (or bankroll). Extending this logic out further, if you were to go “all in” on every single bet even if the coin were weighted in a manner such that you win 99.999999999% of the time, the EG = -100% if you are allowed to flip the coin infinite many times despite the fact that your EV would be exploding to infinity. The math of investing isn’t as simple as winning and losing as in the case, I present above. You get to input distributions of possible results with probability distributions of those results. In the end, you get to the indisputable truth that BET SIZING MATTERS (portfolio allocation sizing matters). The math gets way more complicated than this and frankly, I don’t truly understand it yet. The key takeaways from this fun math end up being quite intuitive: The better the investment (in terms of expected return and likelihood of success), the greater the percentage of your portfolio that you should allocate to this investment. If you overbet (oh what a horrible screen name to have for this discussion) or underbet, you will not maximize your expected growth. If you underbet in a +EV situation, you still will expect to grow your portfolio. If you overbet in a +EV situation, expected growth of your portfolio can be positive or negative. The penalty of underbetting (in general) is less severe than the penalty of overbetting. While I think the guidelines Chris DeMuth lays out are not necessarily all that bad in practice, I would caution taking an overly simplistic approach to a (very) complex problem.

QLC: Large-Cap ETF With High-Quality Stocks

Summary QLC is an equity fund focusing on large-cap companies that are financially strong, have low valuation, and have positive performance. I compare QLC’s portfolio to four categories of large-cap ETFs, with a total of 16 ETFs being compared. There are some interesting characteristics to be found in large-cap ETFs that may be of interest in trying to choose an effective investment. A serious all-ETF portfolio needs at least one fund that focuses on large-cap U.S. equities ; arguably, large-cap companies are the mainstay of the American economy and, as a result, large-cap holdings are arguably the mainstay of any portfolio. There are currently at least 118 ETFs that focus, in one way or another, on U.S. large caps. 1 There are a variety of ways of approaching such a target: sector, size, growth, value, dividend yield, earnings, fundamentals – what have you. For its part, Northern Trust Investments ‘ FlexShares Funds recently issued a new fund: the FlexShares U.S. Quality Large Cap Index Fund (NASDAQ: QLC ). As I looked into this fund I found some interesting things that lead me to believe this ETF may have tremendous potential. The Fund The index used to model the fund’s portfolio consists of the 600 largest companies among the companies listed in the Northern Trust 1250 Index . 2 Companies are selected on the basis of three criteria: “Companies that exhibit financial strength and stability relative to the broader universe of eligible securities.” “Securities trading at lower valuations .” Stock that is displaying ” positive momentum .” 3 The weighting applied to holdings is also determined by the three criteria listed above. The fund is rebalanced/reconstituted quarterly. 4 In view of the potential frequency of reconstitution, the ER of 0.32% seems reasonable. There would seem to be the likelihood of a high turnover rate. Distribution of dividends is planned to be quarterly; distribution of capital gains is planned to be made annually. 5 In the table above, my estimate of the fund’s income includes only dividends that may be realized from its holdings as of 6 October 2015. Expenses are my estimate based on NAV (as of 6 October) and ER. The calculation of a dividend yield of 1.80% is based solely on dividend income realized by the fund that would, in principle, be paid to shareholders. 6 ,7 In the course of selecting its holdings, FlexShares manages to maintain diversity in its portfolio: (click to enlarge) Performance As is the case with any new ETF, there is little to go by in terms of the fund’s actual performance. As a substitute, I have been taking the at-the-time current portfolio for the fund and running it back for five years, to give an indication of how that particular iteration of the fund’s index has paid off. I use the weighting for each holding as it is on the day I download the fund’s holding. This may not be exactly precise , but it would be practically impossible to accurately weigh the portfolio’s holdings as they would be weighted by the index over the past five years – particularly when the weighting system is a proprietary one, as it is for QLC . The test is done with an initial $25,000 in funding. The basic performance of QLC ‘s portfolio since 1 October 2010 is reflected in the following chart: (click to enlarge) The growth of the portfolio has been fairly steady, although it does reflect the poor market conditions of the past few months. The total performance over the five years has been 103.85%. By itself, of course, the performance of the portfolio – while attractive – does not give any indication of it compares to the market in general. The following chart compares QLC ‘s portfolio to three indices: the S&P 500 , the Dow Jones Industrial Average , and the Dow Jones U.S. Large-Cap Index . 8 (click to enlarge) The performance of QLC portfolio has been quite nice when compared to the performance of the three indices; it has outperformed the S&P and the Large-Cap Index by more than 300bps , and has nearly 500bps over the DJIA. This piqued my interest. If the QLC portfolio did well compared to relevant indices, how would it look compared to other large-cap-focused ETFs? To see how the performances would compare, I performed four trials: QLC versus Large-Cap ETFs that did not use specialized focus (“straight”). QLC versus “growth” oriented large-cap ETFs. QLC versus “value” oriented large-cap ETFs. QLC versus large-cap ETFs that based selection on specialized criteria (“alternative-factor”). In each case but one I compare QLC to four other ETFs; in the case of “alternative-factor” ETFs there are only three “competitors” – most of these funds are relatively new, with less than two or three years performance to consider. 9 The four straight large-cap ETFs are: iShares Russell 1000 ETF (NYSEARCA: IWB ) iShares Morningstar Large-Cap ETF (NYSEARCA: JKD ) SPDR S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA: SPY ) Vanguard Large-Cap ETF (NYSEARCA: VV ) (click to enlarge) The growth-oriented ETFs consist of: iShares Russell Top 200 Growth ETF (NYSEARCA: IWY ) SPDR S&P 500 Growth ETF (NYSEARCA: SPYG ) Vanguard Growth ETF (NYSEARCA: VUG ) Vanguard Russell 1000 Growth ETF (NASDAQ: VONG ) (click to enlarge) The value large-cap ETFs include: Guggenheim S&P 500 Pure Value ETF (NYSEARCA: RPV ) iShares Russell 1000 Value ETF (NYSEARCA: IWD ) SPDR S&P 500 Value ETF (NYSEARCA: SPYV ) Vanguard S&P 500 Value ETF (NYSEARCA: VOOV ) (click to enlarge) The three alternative-factor ETFs are: First Trust Capital Strength ETF (NASDAQ: FTCS ) Guggenheim S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF (NYSEARCA: RSP ) PowerShares S&P High Quality (NYSEARCA: SPHQ ) (click to enlarge) In all four trials, only one ETF was able to rise to the occasion: Guggenheim’s RPV , in the “value” category; indeed, until this year, RPV outperformed QLC’s portfolio, and did it quite handily. While 15 ETFs may not be a very large selection of the 117 (besides QLC ) large-cap ETFs, it would seem to constitute a representative sampling. To the extent that is true, there would seem to be very little to differentiate between the various funds out there. The overall range of 74.20% to 94.74% (( RPV )) belies the fact that (A) RPV exceeds the performance of all other ETFs (other than QLC ) by at least 600bps; (B) as a group, the growth-oriented ETFs outperformed the other groupings, clustering between 88.02% (( SPYG )) and 87.15% (( IWY )) – a spread of 87bps; (C) the ETFs in each grouping tend to cluster together, within a few hundred basis points of each other. In any event, the portfolio of companies currently held by QLC far outperforms the competition. Whether this will translate into outperformance in the future remains to be seen, and past performance can never be taken as an indication of future performance. That being said, however, there is more than passing cause for some optimism here. Assessment There are a couple of observations that can be made, but let’s start with QLC : the fund seems to have a lot going for it. If the success of QLC ‘s portfolio can be attributed to the formula used by Northern Trust’s indices, this is certainly an ETF to keep an eye on. It would definitely be a fund to put on one’s watchlist – it might bear watching until it has a year behind it, to get a better idea of turnover rate, ultimate distribution yield and trading volume/liquidity; it is simply too early to get a feeling for these. I have put QLC on my watchlist as a potential replacement for the PowerShares S&P 500 Low Volatility ETF (NYSEARCA: SPLV ), or to compliment it. What seems to be something of interest (at least, to me ) is RPV . This ETF outstripped it value-based brethren, and outperformed everything but QLC ; in general, however, each grouping had a tendency to cluster. It might be worth further investigation if one is interested in finding a large-cap ETF that has proven potential . The only real question I have is why it has experienced a drop this year that has been disproportionately worse than that experienced by other large-cap funds. As for the large-cap funds in general, it looks as if the growth-oriented funds are where the best performance (as a group) are to be found. There is a fairly large gap behind the growth cluster, with the alternative-factor cluster coming in next, straight cluster third and value ETFs bringing up the rear. Except for RPV . Disclaimers This article is for informational use only. It is not intended as a recommendation or inducement to purchase or sell any financial instrument issued by or pertaining to any company or fund mentioned or described herein. All data contained herein is accurate to the best of my ability to ascertain, and is drawn from the Company’s Prospectus, Statement of Additional Information, and fact sheets. All tables, charts and graphs are produced by me using data acquired from pertinent documents; historical price data from The Wall Street Journal . Data from any other sources (if used) is cited as such. All opinions contained herein are mine unless otherwise indicated. The opinions of others that may be included are identified as such and do not necessarily reflect my own views. Before investing, readers are reminded that they are responsible for performing their own due diligence; they are also reminded that it is possible to lose part or all of their invested money. Please invest carefully. ——————– 1 A recent search on the ETF.com screener shows 118 funds when U.S. large-cap funds are searched. 2 Which, as one might expect, consists of the 1250 largest companies (by market cap) in the U.S. 3 FlexShares Trust Prospectus, FlexShares US Quality Large Cap Index Fund (QLC), p. 1. My emphasis. Prospectus is available here . A company’s “financial strength and stability” is measured by proprietary formula. A stock’s momentum is calculated regularly by the index. 4 Prospectus, p. 1. 5 Prospectus, p. 15. 6 Investors are reminded that the income distributed by an ETF is not limited to dividends it has received from its holdings. ETFs also distribute capital gains, interest received, as well as income from other instrumentalities. My estimate is typically below the sum actually paid out by the fund. 7 I am trying out some new data. In addition to my “expense margin” (how much is left after expenses are taken out of gross income), I have added “income yield” (gross income divided by NAV) and “return on NAV” (RONAV) (net income divided by NAV). All of these are intended to reflect aspects of ETF performance the way certain data reflect the performance of a company (operating margin, sales to assets, ROA, respectively). Certainly, some of this data will be more meaningful once a fund has a year’s worth of activity behind it. 8 This is in no way intended to make any claim about the performance of QLC – which didn’t exist until September, 2015; nor is it intended to make any claim about the future performance of the fund. 9 I wanted to limit the comparisons to funds with 5 years of performance history, for sake of fairness.

Xilinx: Climbing Out Of The ‘Trough’?

Xilinx (XLNX) stock gapped up Thursday after the chipmaker late Wednesday reported fiscal Q2 earnings that beat Wall Street’s views by 2 cents, despite falling 23% vs. the year-earlier quarter. CEO Moshe Gavrielov said Xilinx was already climbing out of its “trough.” “I don’t see us returning to that previous peak, which I believe was in the March 2014 quarter, anytime soon,” he told analysts in the company’s earnings conference call. “I do expect