Author Archives: Scalper1

Alliance Resource Partners: Circle Of Competence In Action

Summary The concept of a circle of competence is probably more important to avoiding risk than anything else, but it is not discussed enough in context. Coal is obviously hated right now. I can’t think of anything more universally hated. That can mean opportunity. And Alliance’s track record is incredible. Just looking at the financials, you would never guess that this is a commodity company. But I don’t understand the legal/regulatory environment and the price of coal in the Illinois Basin has declined to a point that implies breakeven EBITDA for ARLP. Circle of competence is probably the most important concept in investing for avoiding catastrophic risks. Most people can understand some businesses, but everyone has many businesses they do not understand well enough to touch at any price. Understanding can be changed. You can learn, but that should be done before making investment decisions regarding the businesses you don’t understand. Circle of competence gets a lot of attention among value investors, but still not as much as it deserves, and where it is discussed, it is usually abstract because no one wants to discuss specific things they don’t understand. It’s tough on the ego. That’s exactly what I’m going to try to do here. Coal I don’t understand coal. Alliance Resource Partners LP (NASDAQ: ARLP ) came up on my list of low EV/EBIT stocks. To this point, I’ve been dismissing MLPs entirely, but I decided to give this one a chance. This is important because I’ve never invested in an MLP before, so there’s already a layer of non-understanding here. The MLP issue is not the crux of it. It looks like MLPs are publicly traded limited partnership interests. Only companies in certain industries like commodities can structure as MLPs. They aren’t taxed at the corporate level, and distributions (not “dividends”) are return of capital – they lower your cost basis but are not taxed immediately in most cases. When you sell, your capital gain (hopefully you have a positive total return) is taxed at your ordinary income rate, not at capital gains rate. You should always own MLPs in taxable accounts because they are actually taxed preferentially there compared to in a tax-exempt account like an IRA. Great, so maybe I could own an MLP. But coal is another story. Coal must be one of the most, if not the most, hated industry out there right now. The industry ETF (NYSEARCA: KOL ) is down almost 50% over the last 12 months: (click to enlarge) Environmentalists hate it because it produces more CO2/energy produced than other energy sources. Coal produces 2000 lb of CO2 per ton, while gas (natural gas is its closest competitor) produces 1100 CO2. The government hates it because environmentalists hate it and environmentalists are voters. There are also reasonable negative externalities but I’m trying to be pragmatic. Investors hate it because the stocks have been killed to the point where it’s tough to be an institutional investor and hold anything related to it. Utilities hate it because its controversy is causing them to spend billions converting electric power plants to gas-powered and other energy sources. Kids hate it because it’s what they unwrap on Christmas instead of the things they actually wanted or could do anything with. I may or may not be able to keep going, but you get the point. My insight was that there might be a market prejudice in all this hate and maybe there is opportunity in the pessimism on coal. Alliance in particular looked interesting. Despite being a cyclical, commodity business, the financials look really interesting. Operating income has been positive every year over the last 10 years, and substantially so with OM% never getting below 13%. FCF conversion from EBIT has been about .6x, unheard of in my experience for a commodity business. Book value per share has compounded from 1.68 to 14.16. Revenue has grown every single year. The share count has not been diluted at all… Just unusually fantastic long-term numbers. (click to enlarge) And the stock price has done well long-term: (click to enlarge) There’s a really informative post from Value Investors Club that perfectly laid out the bull case on the stock. It’s quite compelling. The company has been led by Joe Craft since the mid ’90s and he’s been with the company since he left college around 1980. He owns a substantial interest in both the GP and ARLP and is thus properly incentivized. He only takes a salary of $700k/yr. Apparently, ARLP is a low cost producer generating some 95% of its coal in the low-cost Illinois Basin. I don’t know much about commodities, but I know being the low-cost provider is everything in terms of competitive dynamics. ARLP stock now trade at an EV/FY15 est. distributable cash flow of like 4.3x. And a third of that EV is debt. In other words, they could hypothetically pay a ~33% distribution. This all sounds great, except that there are many things I just don’t understand about coal. One is regulation. According to John Huber , there is regulation in the works that could force utilities to move away from coal: Adding to the cyclical woes are the regulatory hurdles that the industry currently faces, and will likely continue to face going forward. The US Supreme Court remanded the EPA s Mercury and Air Toxic Standards on June 29th , which would have cost power plants upwards of $10 billion annually. This was perceived as a victory for the coal industry, but many power plants have already been converting from thermal coal to natural gas in anticipation of regulatory requirements. Who knows what lower courts will decide regarding mercury emissions, but once a plant switches to gas, it’s not going back to coal regardless of price. Then there is the unrelenting decline in coal prices. In the Illinois Basin in particular, coal prices have declined to a point that implies breakeven EBITDA for Alliance: (click to enlarge) Source: Quandl / US Energy Information Administration . I don’t know how their margins will hold up given that. The current 20% operating margin seems unusually high for a commodity company. Maybe ARLP will even lose money this time around. I just can’t get comfortable with this. I’m using too many “maybes.” Even if ARLP is attractive now on an expected value basis, without a great deal of knowledge, there’s no way for me to say with any degree of certainty in the face of declining coal prices that my downside is limited. And that’s a requirement for my portfolio. I may do further work here, but for now coal and ARLP are getting put in the “don’t understand/too hard” pile. Hopefully this not only provides some information about coal and ARLP, but serves as an example of the circle of competence concept in action.

EVV And EVG: 2 More Eaton Vance Funds That Sound Alike, But Aren’t

Eaton Vance Limited Duration Income Fund sports a nearly 9.5% yield. Eaton Vance Short Duration Diversified Income Fund’s yield is around 8%. The risks involved favor the lower yield. Financial markets are in a state of flux right now. With the Federal Reserve continuing to keep interest rates at low levels, some might argue that there’s no need to worry. However, the Fed is keeping rates low because of weak global growth — certainly not a good thing. And how long can rates stay this low before unintended consequences start to rear their ugly heads? If you are the least bit concerned about the markets and interest rates Eaton Vance Limited Duration Income Fund (NYSEMKT: EVV ) and Eaton Vance Short Duration Diversified Income Fund (NYSE: EVG ) both sound like good places to hide in a storm. But that’s worth a closer look… Birds of a feather? EVV and EVG both share a similar mandate, providing investors with a high-level of current income. Capital appreciation is a secondary consideration for each. In addition, both closed-end funds, or CEFs, try to provide broad exposure to the fixed income markets while limiting interest rate risk. EVV’s duration is targeted to be between two and five years, while EVG is a little more conservative in that its duration is expected to be no more than three years. Although that’s a difference, it’s not exactly a huge one. At the end of the second quarter, EVV’s duration was around 3.2 years and EVG’s was around 2.1 years. Both funds, meanwhile, make use of leverage, something that can increase gains in good times but exacerbates losses in bad times. EVV and EVG even share five of six managers (EVV has six people steering the boat, EVG only five). One big difference between the pair is size. EVV has more than six times the assets of EVG, which helps explain why there’s an extra hand at the wheel. But this isn’t the only difference you’ll want to be aware of. The big obvious one for most investors will be the distribution yield. EVV’s yield is around 9.4%, roughly 17% higher than EVG’s 8%. That said, the yields are based on NAV at both funds, which are trading at over 10% discounts and are more reasonable, with EVV’s NAV yield at around 8.1% and EVG’s NAV yield of just about 7%. Based on this quick look, you might just go for the higher yield from the larger fund. But don’t jump just yet. A quick look at the engine Although duration is very important in the bond world, since it gives you an idea of the impact that interest rate changes will have on your return, it isn’t the only factor to watch for. (The longer the duration, the more impact interest rate changes will have.) Another important one is credit quality. While short durations can help to limit the risk of lower quality debt, since it will get paid off relatively quickly, it doesn’t remove the risk. And with investor concern high, low-quality debt has been taking a big hit. Perhaps rightly so. And that’s an important comparison point at EVV and EVG. At the end of the second quarter, EVV’s portfolio was made up of about 30% investment grade debt. So 70% of what it owns could be characterized as high-yield or “junk.” To be fair, BB, the highest-quality high-yield debt, makes up about 30% of that, but it still has heavy exposure to risky borrowers. EVG, on the other hand, had about half of its portfolio in investment grade issuers. There was another 25% or so in BB issuers. Of the two, EVG’s exposure to credit risk is much less than its sibling’s. That helps account for the lower yield, too, since higher-quality bonds tend to pay less interest than lower-quality fare. For investors concerned about a coming market storm, then, EVG appears to the less risky option. True, it has a lower yield, but that might be a worthwhile trade-off if you were looking at EVV and EVG to find a “safe” short-duration CEF bond fund to hide in. That said, there are some other factors to consider, too. For example, EVG’s portfolio is about two-thirds U.S. debt. EVV’s U.S. exposure is higher at around 85%. You could look at this difference in one of two ways. On the one hand, more diversification is better. On the other, sticking close to home may prove to be a more astute choice if the U.S. turns out to be the cleanest dirty shirt if, in my opinion when, the markets hit more turbulence. Then there’s the issue of long-term performance. Over the trailing 10 years through September, EVV’s annualized NAV return, which includes reinvested distributions, was about 6.4%. EVG’s annualized return over that span was about 5%. But that was then, and this is now. For example, over the trailing six months through September, EVG’s NAV loss was around 1.7% and EVV’s loss was nearly 3%. In September alone, EVV lost nearly 2% of its net asset value. EVG fell about 0.5% in September. So it looks like EVG has the edge when risk starts to matter, but EVV’s risk taking has paid off over the longer term. That, of course, is the big trade-off in investing: Risk vs. reward. Right now, I’d err on the side of caution and give EVG the edge if you are watching this pair. That said, if you buy EVG, you might want to keep an eye on EVV for a time when the skies are a little more clear.

Amazon.com Soars To Record High On Strong Q3

If you’re not buying goods via e-commerce leader Amazon.com, you’re in an ever-shrinking population. Amazon.com (AMZN) stock hurtled to an all-time high Friday after the e-commerce juggernaut’s Q3 earnings late Thursday beat analyst views, with the bottom line swinging to an unexpected profit despite the company’s continued heavy spending on growth. Revenue rose 23% year over year, matching the company’s biggest growth in two