Author Archives: Scalper1

The ‘Long 2s’ Of Financial Markets

Summary In honor of the closure of Grantland, an application of sports analytics to portfolio management. In basketball, a long two-point shot is inefficient with a low average return and high variance of returns. This article looks at three similar investment classes in financial markets that similarly produce lower expected returns over time. The news late Friday of ESPN’s shuttering of sports and pop culture website Grantland was disheartening. I liked the mix of long-form journalism and irreverent pop culture topics from a diverse array of skilled young writers, but particularly I loved the articles on deep, and often arcane, sports analytics. As someone with post-graduate studies in analytic finance, the combination of Big Data and some of America’s pastimes spoke to me. Growing up in basketball-crazed Indiana, the articles from Grantland’s Kirk Goldsberry and Zach Lowe allowed me to watch a game I have had a life-long passion for in new and unique ways. One of the simplest and most frequent basketball-related discussion was the inefficiency of the “Long 2”, two-point field goal attempts from just inside the three-point line. A slightly above-average 3-point shooter making 40% of his shots could more than offset a skilled big man making 55% percent of his shots close to the basket. The 1.2 points-per-shot from the 3-point specialist outscored the 1.1 points-per-shot from the post player. The 3-point shooter will score more points on average over time, but of course, sample sizes are not unlimited in a came with a clock. Borrowing from finance, the three-point shooter has higher average returns, but more variable returns from the more difficult shots. If those long shots are not going in with enough frequency, a more steady point scorer can outperform over shorter stretches of time. Now imagine a jump shooter who typically takes long two-point shots, and makes 45% of the shots on average, more than the 3-pt shooter but less than the close range scorer. That shooter scores just 0.9 points per shot. Basketball coaches have realized these shots are inefficient. For investors, these long two point shots with lower expected returns per unit of risk can be said to be below the efficient frontier. In the spirit of Grantland and the inefficiency of the Long 2, I am going to cover three equivalencies in the world of finance, investments that do not offer requisite returns for their relative riskiness. Low Rated Junk Bonds When we learn the Capital Asset Pricing Model in school, we are taught that required returns are proportional to an asset’s (non-diversifiable) risk. The limits of this model can be seen on a basketball court. As you move further away from the basket, your shooting percentage is not going to fall linearly. If you hit 80% of your free throws from 15 feet away from the basket, you are less likely to hit 40% from 30 feet from the basket (8 feet behind the NBA 3-point line) and are even less likely to hit 20% from 60-feet from the basket, or two-thirds of length of a professional court. This analogy can be applied to the debt of corporations. Imagine you are getting paid 5% returns to lend to a company with leverage (Debt/EBITDA) of 3 times. Even if yields paid to investors did rise linearly per unit of leverage (they do not), if you expected to earn 15% returns lending to companies with nine times as much debt as their earnings, you are employing a strategy akin to shooting sixty-footers every time down the court. The only exception is in this example, you can actually see points reduced from your scoreboard in the likely scenario that the 9x levered company goes bankrupt, liquidates its assets, and pays a recovery to bondholders less than the price at which you purchased the securities. Over long-time intervals, it has been shown that buyers of BB-rated bonds (the highest quality junk bonds) outperform buyers of lower rated, higher yielding single-B and CCC-rated bonds. You just aren’t getting paid enough for those more risky shots. For additional evidence of this phenomenon, see: The Low Volatility Anomaly: A High Yield Bond Example or The Winning Trade in High Yield Corporate Bonds High Dividend Stocks Research has shown that stocks paying dividend yields between three to six percent produce higher absolute returns than stocks with yields above six percent. Dividend yields above this threshold are usually a function of lower stock prices and not necessarily higher payouts as the market begins to reflect concerns about the company’s business profile. Companies that are generating enough stable cash flow to support this dividend level could also be signaling to the market that they do not have sufficient internal investments to drive the value of the firm prospectively. S&P 500 companies that have dividend yields above this 6% threshold include businesses from the secularly declining wireline telecom industry – Frontier Communication (NASDAQ: FTR ) and CenturyLink (NYSE: CTL ). Seagate Technology (NASDAQ: STX ), a make of hard drives, would also fit into this declining business model archetype. To me these types of stocks are the Kobe Bryant’s of the investing world. CenturyLink delivered 30% annual returns from 1995-1999. Frontier put up an MVP-like 77% return in 1999. Seagate averaged 20% returns from 2003-2007. These are former all-stars, but their best days may well be behind them. Investors attracted to the flashy dividend yield may see a star, but not recognize that the future is not nearly as bright as the past. For additional evidence on the relative underperformance of high dividend yielding stocks: The Dividend Sweet Spot High Beta Stocks One of my most common themes on Seeking Alpha has been the Low Volatility Anomaly, or why lower risk investments have outperformed their higher risk cohorts. An example of this phenomenon was discussed in the junk bond/sixty-footer analogy. Across markets, geographies, sectors, and time, lower volatility investments have produced higher returns per unit of risk than higher beta investments. Similarly, there have been plenty examples of all-star laden teams that failed to have sustainable success where more disciplined teams have generated surprising outperformance. In 2014-2015, Gordon Hayward (formerly of those great overachieving Butler Bulldog teams) and DeMarre Carroll, the only member of the unexpectedly excellent Atlanta Hawks not named to the All-Star team, both averaged 1.35 points-per-shot. This figure just trailed the performance of LeBron James (1.36 points-per-shot), arguably the best player on the planet. If the NBA were a market exchange, LeBron would likely be the highest priced commodity, but two players who combined last year earned less than LeBron (who is likely vastly underpaid given the salary cap construct) produced similar levels of efficient play by one measure. Low volatility stocks are mis-priced because investors prefer the spectacular alley-oop to good ball movement and an efficient corner three. For more detailed information on why Low Volatility Stocks outperform: 5 Ways to Beat the Market: Part-3 Revisited Those closely guarded pull-up long 2s can be spectacular to watch, but as Grantland showed us, they do not lead to long-run winning performance. Hopefully, this illustration of the Long 2’s of finance can help Seeking Alpha readers build more efficient portfolios.

Creating A Rock Solid Growth Orientated Model Portfolio Of Stocks And Equity Funds

Summary Buy monopoly like businesses with a wide moat. Buy quality companies, ideally with a low debt, low PE and high growth. Buy where there is a strong tailwind (macro theme). When creating an equity portfolio I like to screen stocks and funds according to a eight point checklist. I give most emphasis to the first few points on the list, and where possible try to buy monopolistic stocks at reasonable valuations. 8 point Checklist 1) Monopoly or duopoly (“wide moat”) 2) Quality – liquid, reoccurring & stable earnings, low debt 3) Growth – revenue, earnings 4) Value – low PE 5) Dividends 6) High net profit margin 7) Growing sector or region 8) Strong macro theme, or demographics, low household debt I will briefly discuss each of the above points. 1) Monopoly or duopoly (“wide moat”) A stock that has a high market share in their industry, ideally with high barrier to entry (“wide moat”). These stocks have pricing power and usually strong profit margins, and growing businesses. Some examples would be; Stock exchanges Intercontinental Exchange (NYSE: ICE ), Hong Kong Exchange & Clearing House ( OTCPK:HKXCF ) (HKSE), London Stock Exchange (NYSE: LSE ) are three of the largest global stock and derivatives exchanges. Intercontinental Exchange (owner of the NYSE) has more than one-third of the world’s cash equities volume. Globally there are millions of investors, brokerages, and fund managers, all sending a large portion of their trading business into just a few stock exchanges. Just remember that in bear markets stock exchanges do poorly. Internet search engines Alphabet Google (NASDAQ: GOOG ) (NASDAQ: GOOGL ) and Baidu (NASDAQ: BIDU ) dominate this area and are monopolies. Both have such strong brand recognition that it would be hard for competitors to break in to this area. Both are currently reasonably priced (given their growth and monopoly positions), with Alphabet Google PE of 34 and Baidu PE of 35. Google C non voting stock has recently announced a $5b buyback , and Baidu announced a $1b stock buyback in July. Large Aircraft manufacturers Boeing (NYSE: BA ) and Airbus ( OTCPK:EADSY ) dominate the large aircraft market and have orders booked out years in advance. Smaller players such as Embraer (NYSE: ERJ ) or Bombardier ( OTCQX:BDRBF ), and China’s relatively new entrant Commercial Aircraft Corp of China (COMAC) may well pose some competition in the near future. Chip designers/licensees Arm Holdings (ARMF) has an estimated ~85% market share of the chip design business. It is expected to do well as the next big thing (the Internet of Things (NASDAQ: IOTS )), takes off. It trades on a PE of 34. Another top chip designer to consider would be Skyworks Solutions (NASDAQ: SWKS ) currently on a PE of 18.6. Its stock price is $79, with an analyst target of $113. 2) Quality – liquid, stable, re-occurring earnings, low debt Ideally invest in companies will good stock market liquidity, stable earnings, and ideally reoccurring and growing earnings. A quality company will have a good track record of being well managed, and a strong brand name and reputation such as Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL ). Typically the banks are great for reoccurring earnings provided their loan books are growing. Many IT companies such as Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT ) collect reoccurring earnings each time they release an upgrade. Finally, check that the debt to total capital ratio is low – preferably well below 50%. For example Google’s is only 4.31% . Also look for a high Net Tangible Assets (NTA), or Book Value. 3) Growth – revenue, earnings Ideally find companies that have both growing revenue and Earnings Per Share ((NYSEARCA: EPS )). This way you know they are increasing sales and increasing profit. 4) Value – low PE I prefer to buy at PEs at or below 10 and sell at PEs at or above 20. I break this rule only if companies or funds have exceptional growth outlook or are a monopoly or market dominator. 5) Dividends I view dividends as a nice bonus and a sign the company has good cash flow. Off course the payout ratio should not be too high, so the dividends are sustainable and grow year after year. Be wary of companies that pay a high dividend but cannot sustain it due to EPS falling or weak. 6) High net profit margin Often the companies with low or fixed expenses, low head count, and smart business models, and/or strong pricing power (monopolies) have the highest net profit margins. These companies can be real cash cows. Many of the earlier mentioned companies in the monopoly section are examples of this. 7) Growing sector or region It is much easier to swim with the tide than against it. Try to chose a sector or region that is growing strongly. Right now that would be US technology. The iShares US Technology ETF (NYSEARCA: IYW ) is an easy and safe way to play this. Another strong sector is the real estate funds such as iShares US Real Estate ETF (NYSEARCA: IYR ). real estate does well when interest rates are low or falling. 8) Strong macro theme, or demographics, low household debt My articles on this can be read here. Demographics and Urbanization , The rising Asian middle class , Chinese electric vehicles about to boom , and Take your PIIC – Philippines, Indonesia, India and China . Finally, the table below give an example of the eight point checklist at work. Intercontinental Exchange HKSE GOOGL BIDU Price as of 3 Nov 2015 US $261 HK $199 US $721 US $195 Monopoly/Duopoly Yes Yes Yes Yes Quality Yes – but high debt Yes Yes Yes Growth in EPS Yes – 19.4% Yes -56.8% Low- 5.92% No- minus1.9% Value – low PE No – 23.8 No – 29.8 No – 34.59 No -35.68 Dividend yield 1.1% 3.0% 0.0% 0.0% Net profit margin Good – 35.9% 59.2% 21.2% 20.79 Growth sector Yes – medium Yes Yes Yes Macro theme Energy & stock trading, IPOs China & HK stock trading Global Internet Search, IoTs China Internet Search, IoTs TOTAL 6.5/8 7/8 6/8 5/8 NB: Intercontinental Exchange got a half point for quality due to its slightly higher debt levels of 20.72% debt to total assets. I would be interested to hear from readers if they know of any stocks that score 8/8 on the above checklist. Thank you for reading. Editor’s Note: This article discusses one or more securities that do not trade on a major U.S. exchange. Please be aware of the risks associated with these stocks.